Back to Saratoga

Council meets in closed session Wednesday on Burry-led suit over Pierce Road hillside homes

Citizens for Responsible and Equitable Development, headed by investor Michael Burry, says the city's approval of 25-home Masson Estates ignored wildfire evacuation risk; the developer has called the environmental review thorough.

Knox Abbott

October 4, 20262 min read

Winding hillside road at dusk - illustration, Jake Team LLC

Saratoga's City Council will meet privately with its lawyers on Wednesday, Oct. 7, about the lawsuit challenging its approval of Masson Estates, a 25-home subdivision planned off Pierce Road in the hills near the Mountain Winery.

The 6 p.m. closed session lists the case as Citizens for Responsible and Equitable Development v. City of Saratoga, et al., Santa Clara County Superior Court No. 26CV503751. Closed sessions are not open to the public; the council's regular meeting follows at 7 p.m.

The project

According to the city's project page, Masson Estates would put 25 single-family homes on a 72.45-acre vacant site, with roads, utilities and homes grouped on roughly 18 acres at the north end and the rest left undeveloped except for a 20-foot emergency access road. Five homes would be set aside for lower-income households. The plan calls for removing 367 trees.

The developer applied under the state's builder's remedy, which lets a project bypass local zoning if at least 20 percent of the units are affordable. The Planning Commission denied it on July 8, finding its environmental effects on emergency access and evacuation outweighed its benefits.

On appeal in August, the council approved it unanimously, according to Realtor.com, which quoted one council member saying the approval did not mean the council was dismissing residents' fire and evacuation concerns.

The city's own draft environmental impact report found significant impacts it could not reduce, including on emergency response and evacuation, wildland fire and emergency access.

The lawsuit

The group bringing the case is headed by Michael Burry, the investor portrayed in "The Big Short," according to The Real Deal and Realtor.com.

Its petition argues the city's review did not adequately weigh evacuation risk on Pierce Road, a narrow, winding two-lane road, and cites the city's estimate that the project would add about 70 residents who would use the road to flee a fire.

Realtor.com reported the suit claims violations of the California Environmental Quality Act and the Subdivision Map Act, and also cites a May 2026 study by Fehr & Peers that estimated the project would add about 30 minutes to evacuation times. The petition also raises concerns about special-status plants.

Bill Hirschman of developer Chateau Mission said at the July Planning Commission hearing that the environmental report was "very thorough," The Real Deal reported. The city told Realtor.com it could not comment on pending litigation. A court hearing is scheduled for January 2027, according to Realtor.com.

Sources

saratoga.ca.us

saratoga.ca.us

therealdeal.com

Yahoo

Share

Knox Abbott

Knox Abbott covers Saratoga city hall, the council, and county government.

Related Stories

More in California