Back to Sport

Cagnoni’s Overtime Finish Shows San Jose’s Scoring Trio Sharing the Work

Luca Cagnoni’s first goal in the NHL completed a three-player creation for San Jose, though the Sharks’ blown 3-0 lead kept their opening-night victory from becoming a fairy tale.

Briar Keller

October 2, 20263 min read

NHLFinal
Florida Panthers3
San Jose Sharks4

October 2, 2026

A defenseman’s first goal in the NHL is usually a personal milestone. Luca Cagnoni’s arrived as something more communal: Will Smith sent the puck across the ice, Macklin Celebrini was credited with an assist, and Cagnoni finished 3:14 into overtime to give the San Jose Sharks a 4-3 victory over Florida at SAP Center.

That was the attractive part of San Jose’s regular-season opener for the Bay Area audience that follows the Sharks. Three offensive contributors shared the decisive moment. The less attractive part was the route required to reach it: San Jose led 3-0, surrendered three goals, and needed overtime to secure the win.

Both facts belong in the same paragraph of the season’s first chapter.

A finish with fingerprints everywhere

Cagnoni’s final shot gave him two points, three shots and three blocked shots in 21:17. The overtime goal was his first in the league, but it did not appear in isolation. He had already earned an assist on Smith’s second goal, then later became the player trusted with the finish when Smith found him in space.

The pass is the heart of that overtime play. Smith made the cross-ice pass. Cagnoni released a wrist shot. Celebrini received the additional assist. The scoring sequence gives all three a role, and that matters for a Sharks group that needs offense to emerge from several contributors rather than one player repeatedly solving the same problem.

Smith supplied plenty of the earlier evidence. San Jose’s first goal came from Mason Marchment at 14:20 of the opening period. In the second, Celebrini’s takeaway from Matthew Tkachuk helped create a 2-on-1 shorthanded chance, and Smith converted at 5:52 of the period to make the score 2-0.

Smith struck again on the power play at 10:37. Celebrini and Cagnoni were credited with the assists, and the Sharks had built a three-goal advantage. Smith finished with two goals and an assist. Celebrini had three assists and seven shots. Cagnoni eventually supplied the goal that mattered most.

That is a strong distribution of responsibility for one night. It is also exactly one night.

The lead was real, and so was the escape

Florida made sure the evening could not be filed as a clean celebration. Eetu Luostarinen scored on the power play with 17:10 elapsed in the middle period. He scored again when the third-period clock reached 5:01, and Matthew Tkachuk tied the game 17 seconds later. The Sharks went from comfortable-looking control to overtime before the third period had properly settled.

The sequence exposed a problem that the overtime winner could not conceal. San Jose had created enough offense to build a 3-0 lead, yet its advantage proved fragile once Florida found a response. The Panthers deserve credit for turning the game, particularly through Luostarinen’s two goals and Tkachuk’s equalizer. A victory can be deserved while the performance remains uneven.

The basic shot totals point in San Jose’s favor, 32-26, and Yaroslav Askarov made 23 saves in the win. Florida’s Akira Schmid stopped 28 shots, a reminder that the final margin was one goal and that volume alone does not explain the result. San Jose generated the winning sequence; it also allowed Florida to make the game far more difficult than necessary.

There was context on Florida’s side. Aleksander Barkov left in the second period and did not return, while Gustav Forsling was a late scratch because of an upper-body issue. Those absences limit what this game says about San Jose against a fully intact Panthers lineup. That caveat does not erase the Sharks’ work, but it does keep the night in proportion.

Cagnoni’s finish remains the image worth keeping. Smith’s pass, Celebrini’s involvement and the defenseman’s shot produced a shared creation rather than a solo rescue act. For San Jose, that is an encouraging shape for the offense.

The 3-0 collapse sits directly beside it. The Sharks’ scoring contributors showed they can combine for the winning play; they did not yet make the rest of the game tidy. That is why this was a promising opening night, rather than a season fairy tale.

Sources

NHL: official game statistics

NHL: official game statistics

Source report

NHL: game report

Share

Briar Keller

Briar Keller covers Saratoga high school and area college sports.

Related Stories

More in Weather