Local business? Support local news on SaratogaCA.city

Back to California

State water board approves Delta plan built around Newsom's voluntary deals as federal government threatens to pull out

The State Water Resources Control Board approved the first major Bay-Delta plan overhaul since 1995 on Thursday, with one no vote. Water suppliers and environmental groups both criticized it.

Sasha Lowery· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

October 30, 20262 min read

California's State Water Resources Control Board on Thursday approved a long-debated update to the plan that governs how farms and cities draw water from the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta and the rivers that feed it, CalMatters reports. Board member Nichole Morgan, a civil engineer, cast the lone vote against it.

The update to the Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan, last overhauled in 1995, centers on Gov. Gavin Newsom's so-called voluntary agreements. Water agencies can sign on, giving up some water and paying for habitat restoration, or they fall under a regulatory backup: mandatory rules on how much water has to stay in rivers and streams and flow through the Delta.

The program attached to the agreements, called Healthy Rivers and Landscapes, carries a $2.9 billion price tag paid mostly with state money, plus funds from water suppliers and the federal government, whose share was originally expected to reach $740 million.

The federal question

The Trump administration has threatened to walk away from the deal and take its money with it, though state regulators said no one has formally withdrawn. In a September letter to the board, Aubrey J.D. Bettencourt, principal deputy commissioner of the federal Bureau of Reclamation, accused the board of "executive and regulatory overreach."

Federal officials objected in particular to a new requirement that operators who cut Delta flows submit a plan to make up the loss.

Board executive director Eric Oppenheimer said the plan can work without federal participation, adding, "But we can't make them volunteer." If federal water managers pull out, they would be bound by the backup rules.

Criticism from both directions

Jennifer Pierre, general manager of the State Water Contractors, whose members serve 27 million people and 750,000 acres of farmland, called the plan "unrecognizable" and a "complete system of micromanagement." Westlands Water District has also said the plan is not what it agreed to.

Board chair E. Joaquin Esquivel dismissed claims that the plan strays from Newsom's deal as "convenient theater" and said it "sits where a regulator should." California Natural Resources Secretary Wade Crowfoot acknowledged discomfort with the result and called it "a paradigm shift."

Environmental advocates, tribes and fishing groups argue the agreements and the backup rules both weaken protections for a struggling ecosystem.

Gary Bobker of Friends of the River warned of "a world of confusion and dysfunction," and Barry Nelson of the Golden State Salmon Association said a federal exit would matter more than objections from other water users because the federal government runs the largest Central Valley water project and operates the Delta jointly with the state.

Sources

pleasantonweekly.com

courthousenews.com

Share

Sasha Lowery· AI-assisted, edited by Jake Team

Sasha Lowery writes about community life, schools, public safety, and local events in Saratoga.

Related Stories

More in Sport

Sport

Sharks Shut Out by Sabres 2-0 in San Jose

Buffalo blanks San Jose 2-0 with goals from Olen Zellweger and Zach Benson. The Sharks remain winless on the road against the Sabres this season.

Briar KellerOctober 28, 20261 min read